Why the new female president at Harvard is an exception to the rule.
First in a three-part series
By Kay Steiger, University of Minnesota
Friday February 16, 2007
Harvard University named Drew Gilpin Faust its new president on Feb. 11. Faust, a historian and dean of the Radcliffe Institute for Advanced Study, is now the fourth female Ivy League president. In recent years, she had been considered for the presidencies of the University of Pennsylvania and the University of Chicago, and was widely acknowledged as a scholar and administrator with the credentials to lead a major research university.
Yet her appointment has been widely portrayed in the media as a capitulation to feminists and members of the Harvard liberal arts faculty, many of whom loudly rebelled against former President Lawrence Summers in 2005 after he publicly suggested that the dearth of female faculty in the sciences may be related to genetic differences between women and men. A widely-reprinted Associated Press story on Faust’s appointment noted, “Her selection is noteworthy given the uproar over Summers’ comments.” In a staff editorial, The Harvard Crimson worried, “We hope … that Faust does not arrive at the door of Massachusetts Hall with an unshakeable label as the ‘anti-Summers:’ the woman, the historian, the life-long academic, the gentle administrator.”
Though Faust’s promotion is certainly a watershed moment for women in academia, her success comes amid continued underrepresentation of women on university faculties, particularly in the hard sciences. It’s been 35 years since Congress passed Title IX of the Civil Rights Act, which makes it illegal to discriminate on the basis of sex in any educational program or activity that receives federal funding, including at private institutions. But although women now make up 56 percent of Harvard’s undergraduate population and are predicted to earn more than 60 percent of the university’s master’s degrees and nearly half of doctoral degrees by 2010, only 20 percent of full professors at Harvard are female, according to a study by the American Association of University Professors on gender indicators in higher education. In 2004, which was during Summers’ presidency, only four of the 32 faculty members offered tenure were female.
The numbers at Harvard are indicative of those at many research institutions. On average, women hold only 24 percent of full professorships in the United States.
“I don’t know if [Faust] can change a whole institutional culture,” said Ann Higgenbottom, chair of the Committee on Women in the Academic Profession and a professor of history at Eastern Connecticut State University. Pay disparities may be a particularly intractable problem. The AAUP survey reports that women academics earn 2 to 9 percent less than their male colleagues who hold the exact same rank.
The study points to the process of hiring tenure-track employees. Instead of a formal and open application process, hiring committees often call their colleagues at other institutions and ask for lists of candidates. These lists are often unbalanced, and often all male. The study says, “One department chair reported that when his colleagues made such calls, they got only a list of men. When they called back, and asked specifically whether or not there were any women candidates to consider, the response was often, ‘Oh yes, I just didn’t think of (fill in a woman’s name).’”
Women academics lag farthest behind at the most prestigious research institutions. But since women are receiving advanced degrees in such high numbers, what’s stopping them from filling in the ranks of professorships? The answer is complicated.
Academic jobs—once tenure has been granted—come with almost lifetime job security. Many professors at prestigious institutions achieved tenure well before the percentage of women earning advancing degrees in their subjects approached parity. Since new positions only open up when the university determines a need for faculty to consider a new area of study or when someone retires, promotion can seem to move at a glacial pace in some departments.
The tenure process is a frequently cited culprit contributing to gender disparity, since for many professors it coincides with the years in which people are marrying, buying homes, and starting families. “Family friendly policies are critical. They’re crucial for both men and women. That’s the contemporary world. Any employment sector would be crazy not to be providing supports,” Frances Hoffmann, dean of the faculty at Connecticut College, told Campus Progress.
Academics tend to marry or partner with other academics, and finding a location with two opportunities for couples is sometimes nearly impossible. Catherine Hill, director of research for the American Association of University Women, said she left university life for the nonprofit sector when she and her husband couldn’t find academic positions in the same place. “Men who follow women to their jobs are pretty non-existent. [Universities] haven’t found ways to deal with both members of the couple.”
And in the sciences there are special challenges for women—especially those with primary childcare responsibilities—seeking research funding. “The system is inherently biased against women. There is no reason why a scientist, male or female, has to work 80-hour weeks, or why they should be evaluated on productivity instead of on the value of their science,” said Phoebe Leboy, president-elect of the Association for Women in Science.
Although the number of challenges a woman in academia may face can be daunting, universities are looking at ways to make their institutions more welcoming to women. Some are instituting stop-the-tenure clock policies that allow both men and women to take time for families. And groups like the AAUW are advocating for clearer tenure standards to combat the secretive process that often relies on informal all-male networks.
Taken together, such policies could make academia a more welcoming professional home for future generations of women.
Kay Steiger is the editorial assistant at The American Prospect.
--------
Comments
great article
— john kerry - Feb 16, 07:17 PM - #I concur!!!
— Amberly Carter - Feb 17, 02:45 PM - #timely and balanced…we’ve come a long way, but have far to go on equity, excellence and social responsibility.
— Parker Johnson - Feb 23, 03:40 PM - #I am a retired female Colonel thinking about taking a professor position — great feedback
— R Springer - Feb 23, 04:18 PM - #phentermine overnight prescription no
— prescription or no phentermine - Dec 14, 04:18 PM - #aTUsZA
— JmSDDFkERrHbNq - May 17, 01:23 PM - #it’s nice site swiss made breitling replica watches mqx
— john - May 25, 01:13 AM - #hi nice site thx cheapest propecia xlmb
— joseph - Jun 2, 06:43 PM - #interesting site man cheapest soma nvb
— bred - Jun 2, 11:50 PM - #it’s nice site purchase lipitor 8-)))
— arni - Jun 3, 04:26 PM - #tickets_3.txt;2;2
— iBKQtqshr - Jun 5, 03:25 AM - #AOcmAC breitling replica watches cartier replica watches
— replica - Jun 12, 11:08 PM - #omega replica watches
rolex daytona replica watches
— replica - Jun 13, 06:37 PM - #replica movado watches
chanel replica watches
japanese replica watches
replica luxury watches
cheap replica watches
— replica - Jun 13, 09:46 PM - #replica tag watches
replica man watches
replica rolex watches band
best replica watches
breitling replica swiss watches
— replica - Jun 14, 02:31 AM - #wholesale replica watches china
replica watches store
replica rolex watches for sale
baume mercier replica watches
breitling navitimer replica watches
— replica - Jun 14, 05:42 AM - #replica copy fake watches
ebel replica watches
raymond replica watches weil
top replica watches
breitling navitimer replica watches
— replica - Jun 14, 05:43 AM - #replica copy fake watches
ebel replica watches
raymond replica watches weil
top replica watches
watches china replica
— replica - Jun 15, 05:03 AM - #piaget replica watches
chanel j12 watches replica
replica wrist watches
replica and rolex and watches
replica hermes watches
— replica - Jun 15, 01:56 PM - #lady replica watches
replica watches uk
jacobs replica watches
jaeger lecoultre replica watches
replica louis vuitton
— vuitton - Jun 15, 09:16 PM - #replica louis vuitton diaper bag
replica louis vuitton handbags
replica louis vuitton purse
replica louis vuitton speedy
louis vuitton replica handbag
— vuitton - Jun 16, 01:13 AM - #louis vuitton replica jewelry
louis vuitton replica keepall
louis vuitton replica luggage
louis vuitton replica shoes
replica rolex watches zenith
— replica - Jun 16, 05:19 AM - #replica technomarine watches
replica patek watches
versace replica watches
montblanc replica watchesreplica rolex watches zenith
replica technomarine watches
replica patek watches
versace replica watches
montblanc replica watches
las vegas nia vuitton louis vuitton 2005 loius vuitton jokes louie vuitton bucket purse louie vuitton jacket louie vuitton official site louie vuitton replica handbags louis monogram replica velours vuitton louis vuitton bag bucket louis vuitton bag sale
— louis vuitton - Jul 10, 01:39 AM - #4m5a50 hi! hice site!
— nick - Jul 27, 06:50 PM - #pWORZy hi! hice site!
— nick - Jul 30, 01:45 AM - #i say one thing tramadol no prescription :((
— kate - Aug 1, 05:52 PM - #nice site dude generic ephedrine 3873
— james - Aug 1, 07:08 PM - #i say one thing vicodin no prescription ruvf
— john - Aug 2, 01:55 AM - #interesting post thx designer replica purse loius vuitton 202 louis man replica vuitton :[
— mona - Aug 20, 02:06 AM - #7e8Xof spam_15.txt;5;10
— mHzwaSgoEVQl - Sep 6, 09:17 PM - #g8VuB0 spam_31.txt;5;10
— YamJGSCu - Sep 6, 10:17 PM - #please look at this hydrocodone without prescription xqxka adipex no prescription rxlao
— bob - Oct 7, 08:13 PM - #